Overload on data: Residents continue pushback on facility inquiry in Portland

Residents of Portland, New York, are expressing overwhelming opposition to a potential data center project planned for the former Sugar Hill Golf Course. This public outcry follows a March 11 resolution by the Town Board, which conveyed "general support" for the idea. The second consecutive Town Board meeting regarding this matter saw a standing-room-only crowd, with over 50 attendees voicing unanimous disapproval. Concerns cited by residents include the significant energy and water demands, potential emissions and proximity to Lake Erie, environmental disturbance, and safety. A resident, Kelly Perlette, initiated an online petition that has garnered over 3,100 signatures, and a group called the Grape Belt Community Group has formed, explicitly requesting a moratorium on data centers. Town Supervisor Rich Lewis and Board member Tammy Thompson clarified that the Town Board's initial resolution was merely an "opening of the door" to explore a potential project that could offer substantial financial benefits, especially given that roughly 50% of the town is tax-exempt. Town Attorney Joel Seachrist informed attendees that a moratorium is currently unnecessary, as existing Town of Portland Zoning Laws do not permit data centers in any district, requiring amendments and special use permits before any project could proceed. No formal proposal or site plan has yet been submitted to either the Town Board or the Planning Board. Despite assurances from the Town Board that no immediate action is underway and that the public will be informed of any future developments, residents remain critical of the Board's initial interest, citing a perceived "miscommunication" and "misinformation" fueling their apprehension.