Northern Iowa county panel becomes latest to reject call for data center

Hancock County's Planning & Zoning Commission in Iowa has unanimously voted to deny a request for a zoning change that would allow for the construction of a data center near Garner. The decision, made during a nearly three-hour meeting with a standing-room-only crowd, followed a public hearing where approximately three-dozen people spoke, with the majority opposing the proposed development.

Opponents like Garner resident Doug Merbach argued that the focus should be on supporting existing local businesses rather than attracting new, unknown entities. LeAnn Blanchard raised concerns about the potential negative impact on quality of life, citing constant noise, air pollution, and rising utility costs, which she believes would lower property values. Conversely, Garner city councilman Darrell Schumacher advocated for the rezoning, emphasizing the need for economic development and an "economic boost in the arm" for Hancock County and its schools.

Schumacher presented data on electricity and water usage, citing a Farm Journal article indicating data center electricity use was 4% in 2023 with projections of 9% by 2030, and comparing data center water usage to agriculture and golf courses. The request for rezoning 724 acres of Concord Township from agricultural to industrial for the data center was made by MCNI, a limited liability corporation. MCNI has stated they will likely appeal the Planning & Zoning Commission's decision to the county's Board of Adjustment.